L4M4 Ethical and Responsible Sourcing Questions and Answers

Requesting suppliers to quote in GBP Sterling removes exchange rate risk by fixing the cost in the buyer’s local currency. This strategy aligns with responsible sourcing practices by providing cost stability and protecting the procurement budget from currency fluctuations.

Explanation

the correct answer is 'no- the public sector can choose not to publish information if it is not deemed to be in the public interest'.

They use something called the 'public interest test' to determine if the information should be re-leased or not. For example they may not respond to a request asking how many bullets the UK Army has in storage, as that would be detrimental to national security interests.

Responses to requests are made within 21 days, not 28.

Explanation

Ex-Works has the lowest risk to the supplier- in Exworks the buyer collects the items directly from the supplier - so they have all the issues and risks of transporting it back home.

There are many question on Incoterms CIPS can ask. But as there's such a huge bank of questions it's really hit or miss if you'll get one of those question. Two students sitting the exam at the same time in the same study centre can get different question sets. One person can get 3 Incoterm questions and the other gets 0.

I would learn the major ones- the ones at the ends of the table in particular because these are the ones question are likely to be about. Ex works / Free carrier and Delivered at Place Unloaded/ De-livered Duty Paid in particular.

I like this graph as I'm a visual person. I think it makes it easier to understand than the study guide:

Shipping Incoterms: the Complete Guide - Guided Imports

Explanation

security, consultancy and cleaning are services which are often tendered as they tend to be high value and complex opportunities.

Office supplies and raw materials have less variables so you could use a RFQ for these instead.

A hint for this is also the word services. Security, consultancy and cleaning are services. Raw Materials and Office Supplies are goods.

Weighted criteria allow the buyer to evaluate multiple factors, not just price, to make a fair and balanced decision. This approach ensures responsible sourcing by considering quality, sustainability, and other relevant factors alongside cost, which aligns with public procurement ethics and standards.

DDP (Delivered Duty Paid) requires the supplier to cover all delivery costs, including import duties and taxes. This term ensures that the buyer receives the goods without additional charges, aligning with public sector procurement practices for cost-effective and transparent sourcing.

Payment history and financial stress scores provide insights into a supplier’s financial health and stability. This information is crucial for procurement professionals in assessing whether a supplier can fulfill long-term commitments, supporting responsible sourcing by mitigating financial risks.

Conducting periodic audits by third-party specialists is a reliable way to monitor compliance with ethical standards, as these audits provide an objective assessment. This aligns with ethical sourcing practices, as it promotes accountability and ensures continuous adherence to agreed-upon standards.

Explanation

Coercion is not a type of fraud. The other three are.

Explanation

weighted points systems for assessments should add up to 100. This is 100%.

An example is how this would work is

Price = 50%

Health and Safety questions= 30%

Qualifications = 20%

Explanation

Price and Quality are the two considerations when marking a competitive tender.

Location, distribution and reputation may be considered for SOME tenders, but these would be sub-categories that fall under 'quality questions.

Under the EXW (Ex Works) Incoterm, the buyer assumes responsibility for transportation and export clearance from the seller’s premises. This term aligns with cost-saving measures and the buyer’s internal capabilities for logistics, supporting efficient and responsible sourcing.

In cases where price differentiation is minimal, negotiating on added-value services like after-sales support can offer additional benefits. This aligns with responsible sourcing by focusing on long-term value and fostering a cooperative relationship with the supplier.

Financial stability and supplier reliability are quantifiable factors suited to weighted points systems, allowing procurement professionals to objectively assess and compare suppliers. This method aligns with ethical sourcing practices by promoting fairness and transparency in supplier selection.

Explanation

a factory ordering a new machine is the correct answer.

Strategic sourcing is for high value, high risk items. The other options given are tactical sourcing as they are low value (eggs, paper and plastic cups).

See p.3 for the differences between tactical and strategic sourcing

For low-value, routine purchases where price is the primary consideration, employing a weighted points system may not be necessary. Such systems are more suitable for complex procurements where multiple factors, such as quality, delivery, and sustainability, need to be evaluated alongside price. In the case of purchasing standard items like pens, a straightforward price comparison is typically sufficient.

In addition to price, factors like lead times, add-on costs, and past performance are important to ensure the supplier meets the buyer's requirements sustainably and reliably. These criteria align with ethical sourcing by promoting value and accountability beyond just cost considerations.

Explanation

Incoterms describe who out of the buer and seller; organises transport and what type of transport this is, who pays for insurance, and who organises duty / tariff arrangements when the goods go through customs. See p.131. Note- some students report a lot of questions on Incoterms in the exam, some say they only had 1. If you can, I'd learn them just to be safe.

Explanation

Reasons to outsource include; 'overheads can be kept as effective as possible' and 'the reduction in the need to continually invest in new machinery'.

When you outsource, you transfer the costs of overheads to the supplier and it is their responsibility to buy new machinery as and when is required. For example if you outsource cleaning, the cleaning company is responsible for replacing the hoovers and floor cleaner

The other two options would be reasons to keep something 'in-house'.

The bill of lading serves as both a receipt of goods and a document of title, which means it confirms the contract of carriage and can transfer ownership. Responsible sourcing in international trade requires precise documentation, which is why the bill of lading is critical in verifying both carriage and title.

Payment history and financial stress scores provide insights into a supplier’s financial health and stability. This information is crucial for procurement professionals in assessing whether a supplier can fulfill long-term commitments, supporting responsible sourcing by mitigating financial risks.

Profitability and asset levels indicate a supplier’s financial stability and ability to meet contract demands. Responsible sourcing practices include assessing financial capacity to reduce risk in the supply chain and ensure long-term supplier viability.

Explanation

tactical is the correct answer; items that are short-term or low value are considered tactical.

Strategic sourcing is long term and high value.

Outsourcing is moving a key business function to an external company.

Insourcing is bringing a previously outsourced part of the company back in-house.

A current ratio below 1 suggests that the supplier may not have sufficient current assets to cover short-term liabilities, which could pose a risk to the buyer. Assessing financial stability aligns with responsible sourcing practices, as it ensures suppliers can fulfill contracts without disruption.

Unscheduled audits can provide an unbiased view of supplier practices and help identify compliance issues that might be hidden during scheduled audits. This approach supports responsible sourcing by ensuring accurate assessments of ethical and quality standards.

Explanation

You should investigate automatically low tenders by clarifying the bid with the supplier. It could be they have misunderstood the requirement. Or the bid could be genuine and they can really provide best value for money. But without enquiring, you just don't know.

Evaluating total life-cycle costs, including initial purchase price and long-term maintenance, aligns with ethical sourcing by promoting cost-effective and sustainable procurement. It ensures value for money and supports environmentally and financially responsible sourcing practices.

Evaluating total life-cycle costs, including initial purchase price and long-term maintenance, aligns with ethical sourcing by promoting cost-effective and sustainable procurement. It ensures value for money and supports environmentally and financially responsible sourcing practices.

Incoterms are grouped as E (Ex Works), F (Free Carrier), C (Carriage Paid To), and D (Delivered Duty Paid), reflecting various stages of responsibility transfer between buyer and seller. Understanding Incoterms is critical for responsible sourcing, as it clarifies logistics and cost responsibilities.

Explanation

Incoterms can replace lengthy contract clauses as they replace the need for contracts to detail which party is responsible for organising transport, paying duties, having the insurance etc.

Incoterms is an odd one for exam topics- some students say it was a huge part of their exam and there were many questions on this. Others said there were just one or two. Questions get randomly assigned from the bank so it's completely random how many you'll get on this topic.

Explanation

Most Economically Advantageous Tender (MEAT) is the Public Sector's go to evaluation criteria.

NOTE that this is changing from October 2023. Public Sector Procurement is currently based on legislation called PCR 2015 which itself is based on EU Procurement Directives. Now the UK has officially Brexited, we're making our own laws and the new Procurement Bill will be coming into effect in November 2024. One of the major changes is that MEAT is changing to MAT (most ad-vantageous tender - without the economical bit).

If you're sitting this exam until July 2024- you're fine- learn what the study guide says. If you're taking the exam from November 2024 I'm not sure what students are expected to do. The entire section on public sector procurement is incorrect for you. My best guess is CIPS may removequestions this section as the study guide will be wrong, but I really don't know how they plan to handle this.

The new Procurement Bill - MEAT to MAT - Hempsons - Hempsons

The gross profit margin ratio is calculated by subtracting the cost of goods sold (COGS) from income from sales, then dividing by income from sales. This ratio indicates the profitability of a supplier, a critical factor in assessing financial health, which helps buyers ensure reliable supply continuity.

Explanation

A Category spend is high value and strategic suppliers. C category is low value, high volume of spend aka tail spend. The bits in the middle are B category.

For example when you have a baby you have to buy lots of stuff for it. Your A spend is the big, important and expensive purchases like the pram, cot, carseat. You spend a lot of time in this category because they're important purchases you want to get right. The Tail Spend / C are all thelittle bits like nappies, baby shampoo, sippy cups. The B category are the bits in between - the purchases are kinda important but aren't as strategic or important as A category. Toys may fall into this category.

Explanation

Open tenders should be used when the buyer expects there to be little interest / fewer bids. The opportunity is advertised widely allowing any supplier that wishes to submit a bid the opportunity.

The other options limit the number of suppliers and Ji Yuan doesn't want to do that, because he risks getting no interest and no supplier.

P.23

Incoterms clarify responsibilities between buyers and sellers, reducing certain risks but not eliminating them entirely. Responsible sourcing requires recognising that Incoterms are only part of risk management in international trade, and other factors, such as supplier reliability and quality, must be considered.

Porter's Five Forces and the STEEPLED model are valuable tools for analyzing supply markets. These models help identify external pressures and market dynamics, supporting responsible sourcing by enabling buyers to understand and respond to market influences effectively.

Explanation

Greg needs to use a gearing ratio. Gearing is a measure of how the business is being funded and is based on the ratio of debt to equity Gearing comes up a lot in the exam. Also make sure you know what Return on Investment, Acid Test and EBITDA are.

Return on Investment (ROI): How to Calculate It and What It Means (investopedia.com)

EBITDA: Definition, Calculation Formulas, History, and Criticisms (investopedia.com)

Acid-Test Ratio: Definition, Formula, and Example (investopedia.com)

The Triple Bottom Line framework evaluates an organisation's impact on social, environmental, and economic factors. Financial and environmental performance are critical components, along with social metrics, aligning with responsible sourcing goals to promote sustainability and ethical practices.

Explanation

The correct answer is the CIPS Code of Conduct. This is a voluntary document about doing 'good procurement' i.e. treating suppliers with respect.

EU Procurement Directive is legislation, so isn't voluntary

ISO9001 is about quality management

ILO is an organisation rather than a document

Addressing human rights issues collaboratively by developing an action plan allows for improvement and correction. This approach is consistent with ethical sourcing principles, which encourage responsible intervention to correct and improve supply chain practices rather than punitive measures that may not lead to long-term change.

Explanation

Cleaning and Facilities Management are the most appropriate items to outsource. They would not outsource the making of confectionary products as this is the 'core' business.

See p.4 for "what is outsourcing?"

To maintain integrity and avoid conflicts of interest, Tracey should declare the conflict and remove herself from the tender process. Ethical sourcing practices emphasize transparency and fairness, which prevent potential biases and maintain trust within procurement processes.

Outsourcing can lead to a loss of control over certain aspects of a project, as the organization relies on external parties to deliver services or products. Additionally, sharing sensitive information with third-party vendors increases the risk of data breaches or loss of private information. While there may be concerns about assets or future business opportunities, the primary risks in outsourcingrelate to control and information security.

Providing a debrief allows suppliers to understand the tender process and learn areas of improvement, promoting transparency. This practice supports responsible sourcing by fostering a fair, competitive environment and encouraging suppliers to improve their future offerings.

Explanation

the correct answer is 'marketplace competition'.

Ethical practice is about prohibiting corrupt and unfair practice, rather than issues of supply and demand. Although being in a cartel is 'unethical behavior' this option doesn't fully answer the question which talks about limiting supply- this is related to marketplace competition.

Explanation

ethics and environment are not a 'right of procurement'.

The 5 rights are price, quality, quantity, time and place.

Explanation

One of the biggest advantages to making an item over buying it is 'improved quality control'.

When you make the product yourself, you can set the quality parameters you require and aren't re-stricted to, or dependant on, what the supplier does. The other options are incorrect- making stuff inhouse would mean you hold more inventory. If the supplier has a higher skillset than you, you would outsource. Threat of substitutions wouldn't impact this decision.

For a list of pros and cons relating to the 'make or buy' decision see p.5. This is a hot topic for the exam.

Explanation

These are 'not-for-profit' organisations. You don't need to know much on not-for-profit procurement for this exam. Just that procurement can be regulated in this sector by bodies such as Charities Commission.

Under the EXW (Ex Works) Incoterm, the buyer assumes responsibility for transportation and export clearance from the seller’s premises. This term aligns with cost-saving measures and the buyer’s internal capabilities for logistics, supporting efficient and responsible sourcing.

Explanation

The correct answer is 'demand is exceeding supply'- If everyone wants to buy something, the sup-pliers will likely increase the price.

If there was little demand or there were threats of substitutions, this would likely result in a price decrease.

Public sector sourcing prioritises maintaining service levels within budget constraints and often mandates competitive tendering to promote transparency and fairness. These principles align with ethical sourcing practices, ensuring responsible expenditure and fair competition among suppliers.

Explanation

liquid = the ability to pay short and medium term debts. In simple terms do you have more in stuff (money, assets) than you owe in debt?

Understanding Liquidity and How to Measure It (investopedia.com)

This is a hot topic for the exam. Learn everything in this section.

Explanation

you would use a restricted approach when interest is likely to be high. The buyer needs a method of de-selecting unsuitable bidders and creating a shortlist of acceptable organisations.

For complex requirements you could use both an open or restrictive tender- the difference between the approaches is about how many bids you're likely to get rather than the complexity of it.

Explanation

Incoterms describe the point at which an item is considered 'delivered' and explains who has the risk of what during the transport of the goods.

Ordering in November, when demand is lowest, may allow the buyer to secure better pricing and availability, aligning with responsible sourcing by optimizing purchase timing to achieve cost savings and reliable supply.

Explanation

Social value is about benefitting the local community / society. Therefore of those options listed, use of local labour is the most appropriate to consider.

Capacity and compatibility are critical factors in supplier appraisal. Evaluating these factors ensures that the supplier can meet the buyer’s requirements in terms of production capacity and aligns with responsible sourcing by ensuring the supplier’s values and practices are compatible with the buyer’s expectations.

An Invitation to Tender (ITT) is typically used for complex, high-value procurements where the quality and specific features of the goods or services are of paramount importance. This approach ensures that ethical and responsible sourcing criteria are met, aligning with best practices in procuring specialised goods or services.

Explanation

The correct answer is 'gearing ratio'.

Gearing measures how much of a company's funding is based on long-term debt or loans- this would be affected by a steep rise in inflation. If a company has a mortgage on their offices or facto-ry and they need to remortgage and inflation has gone up a lot- they'll be paying a lot more on their mortgage. This will severely effect the gearing ratio as they'll have more outgoings than incoming.

Gross profit margin COULD be affected by inflation, for example if you've got hyper-inflation and the country goes into recession and people stop buying your product. However, this answer isn't al-ways right and depends on many factors- the industry, the product, the company etc, so for the purpose of CIPS should be discounted. There are many industries which are immune to inflation.